noylj posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 8:58am

This would be a good one shot. I hope that it is not just 2 chapters.
How is Harry going to discover horcruxes if DoubleDumb took the information to his grave? What would be nice is if Moldie really lost his magic and would be no more than a wraith for all eternity, without the magic to affect the world around him. Who has to defeat/vanguish a powerless wraith?

Aberforth's Avatar posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 8:50am

I really like this story. The even pacing and its character focus is refreshing. The slowly developing romance between Harry and Hermione is sweet, and I especially like the toned down angst from Harry. It's fun to see 'what might have been' as Harry gets his wish from the end of Prisoner...

Thanks for sharing this with us.

AK posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 8:40am

Nice story, interesting plot, blah blah blah ... the usual.

But if I can make one request? Use less italics please. Like half or more of the story (err chapter) is in italics and it simple hurts my eyes to read that much. Maybe you can think of a different way to separate letters from normal text. But in my opinion the header is enough.

Jim_xinu posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 8:05am

From "London, England, June 25th 1995..." on there are several sections italized that shouldn't be.

Good chapter, thanks for sharing it with us.

MadMax666 posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 7:42am

A great story, with an interesting premise. Please keep up the good work!

grenouille posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 7:39am

Good story so far. What's with the reaction to the animagus potion, though? Are we to guess that he's not one, or is he going to be a Horta, or something else as alien?

kellygreenpassion posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 7:37am

I can not wait for Ron to find out that harry is the one Hermione has been seeing all along. Sparks are going to fly there let me tell you and what about the rest of the Weasley's Molly will not be HAPPY

Frank Hacklander posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 7:36am

Another great chapter. The italics were a little mindboggling, but I managed to slog through to the end. I think you're doing a nice job of developing Harry/Hermione and it looks as though you're going to sort out Sirius so that begs the question of whether Remus still pairs off with Tonks. Not sure how I feel about Ron's redemption, but if you can make it believable, so much the better. Regardless, thanks for the update. Can't wait for the next one.

Kaerion posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 7:34am

I'm loving this story so far, and I don't see that changing. As much as I usually prefer more action-oriented fics (like Sunset/Sunrise), I also love the more light hearted ones, like this one seems to be. I haven't read through your other reviews, but based on some of your comments (and how well I know the fanfic-community), I assume you have and will be getting complaints, but I strongly feel that variety in fics is a very good thing; reading the "same" fics over and over again would get very boring, very quickly, so I'm glad you're doing something different. And so far, this is just as excellent as I've come to expect of your writing.

It will be very interesting to see how things turn out, especially now that McGonagall has some suspicions (and Hermione will be going back to Hogwarts soon, where I expect she'll be facing an interrogation :) ), and having Sirius getting involved with a muggle who's so similar to him in personality is just a recipe for disaster (in a good way, hopefully!).

Keep up the great work, I'm already looking forward to the next chapter!

rathvander posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 6:55am

Man I know several people I'd positively love to use that semi-frozen globe of water on. Oh the fun I would have ;D.

Wasn't expecting another chapter so this was a very pleasant surprise.

Many thanks and since I don't have an llamas how about an alpaca?

~Rath

Darke Gray posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 6:44am

Well, I am happy to have another of your stories to read, a new one at that. I have read Sunset so many times... Anyways, when I read the first chapter I thought it was going to be another one-shot like 'Wizard's Fall', but I am glad it is a chaptered story. I really enjoy your writing and can't wait to see where you take this story. I loved the whole first chapter and the prank and everything. I also like how you broke up this chapter and added humor, especially with the Quibbler stories. I can't wait to see more.

DG

Memo posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 6:34am

Maybe Comedy/Drama/FluffyRomance would have worked better? I guess I was expecting something more realistic and not as sugar-coated.
It's not a criticism. Well, not a serious one. I'll just skip this one and hope for the best for your next fic. Maybe the characters will even change their sob story a little next time. I can always hope.

DrT posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 6:34am

There's nothing wrong with the pacing of the story. I am really enjoying it so far. So, keep it up! The Quibbler articles are interesting, and I esp. liked the inflatable shark.

"T"

Drake posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 6:28am

<.< too bad that emu wasn't an emo.

Dumbledore seemed to be understated in canon, there is so much about him that was never explained, for all we know he really was a dark wizard wannabe who semi-repented. And those bikini scenes seemed very tastefully done in my opinion. Too often stories go from Y to NC-17 too quickly.

Evan Mayerle posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 6:23am

Quite the interesting chapter there with lots of character development, some plot development, but a whole lot of character development. *wicked chuckle* It does sound as if Minerva's caught on, thanks to that bauble of Albus'; somehow I doubt she's going to make too much of it, other than to pass a message through Hermione offering any help she can give (if she only knew!!). It'll be quite interesting to watch their relationship grow as well as watch the relationships around them, Sirius/Cindy, Neville/Ginny, et al. I do wonder how long Ron will stay in his "prathood" stage before maturing? Then again, I'm not totally certain he ever did in canon.

Oh, one thing Minerva could definitely help them with is getting in to properly ward the Chamber (or at least Slytherin's Chamber, if there's more than one) against Nagini. If Nagini/Tom has already found the remains of basilisk, I'd give rather poor odds for Lucius' continued survival and only slightly better odds for Narcissa and Draco.

Jujuberry posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 5:57am

Yay, a new chapter! So great- thanks for the clarification, the explanation of ring magic (great idea there), and the Horcrux hunt is shaping out to be awesome. Does this mean we might get to see Indiana Potter?

And Ron'll wise up? Cool, can't wait to see what happens with the rest of the Weasley family.

Thanks so much for another great chapter!

Memo posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 5:51am

I was unable to end the chapter. Too much sugar for me, sorry.

Bobmin356 replied:

Gee ya think that might be why it's classed as a Comedy/Drama/ROMANCE? :D

Greg Johnson posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 5:46am

Another great chapter. Can't wait for the next one. Keep up the good work.

Bedrup posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 5:45am

This sure has some interesting angles. But I ´m a bit cencerned for my diabetes.

James Barber posted a comment on Monday 15th October 2007 5:36am

Hey I'm sorry that I kinda forgot to leave a review on the first chapter of this fine and outstanding story! I'm having computer problems you see where I get the dreaded blue screen of death every two hours unless I reboot before then, which lets it reboot and come back up a whole lot easier let me tell you that!

But anyway outstanding story like always you and your wife are one hell of a team, excellent writers and extremely gifted storytellers to boot!

Simply love this story, oh and the budding romance of Harry and Hermione and also the focus rings are way cool. but got one question for you! Where's Dobby!?! I think at this time he should be at hogwarts didnt he deliver something for christmas to Harry in his dorm during 4th yr, so what you need to do is have him bring something to Harry Potter sir Grangey and from that he can instinctly know where his beloved Harry Potter sir is at and immediately go to him offering him his services!

Bobmin356 replied:

Dobby plays only a very minor, invisible role in this story. In fact he's been hired on by Sirius and is working at Grimmauld Place, but we won't see much of him until Harry returns to Britain.